UN officers — World Points

Filippo Grandi, the UN Excessive Commissioner for Refugees, and Volker Türk, the UN Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights, issued a joint statement calling on the UK Authorities to rethink its plan to switch asylum seekers to Rwanda.

This association seeks to shift duty for refugee safety, undermining worldwide cooperation, Mr. Grandi added.

“The brand new laws marks an extra step away from the UK’s lengthy custom of offering refuge to these in want, in breach of the Refugee Conference,” he mentioned. “Defending refugees requires all nations, not simply these neighbouring disaster zones, to uphold their obligations.”

As an alternative, the UK ought to take sensible measures to deal with irregular flows of refugees and migrants, based mostly on worldwide cooperation and respect for worldwide human rights regulation, the UN officers mentioned.

Raises dangers for asylum seekers

The asylum and immigration laws, recognized generally because the Security of Rwanda invoice, was tabled earlier than Parliament alongside the UK-Rwanda Asylum Partnership Treaty after the UK’s Supreme Court docket discovered final 12 months that the proposed switch of asylum seekers to the African nation would breach worldwide and UK regulation.

The court docket’s determination had famous weaknesses in Rwanda’s system for figuring out particular person asylum claims.

However, the invoice and the treaty don’t in follow overcome the safety gaps recognized by the Supreme Court docket, the UN officers said, including that after enacted, the measures will limit the UK courts from correctly scrutinising elimination selections, leaving asylum seekers with restricted room to enchantment even when they face vital dangers.

New invoice units ‘a dangerous precedent’

Mr. Türk mentioned the invoice infringes on the rule of regulation.

“By shifting duty for refugees, decreasing the UK’s courts’ capability to scrutinise elimination selections, proscribing entry to authorized cures within the UK and limiting the scope of home and worldwide human rights protections for a selected group of individuals, this new laws significantly hinders the rule of regulation within the UK and units a dangerous precedent globally,” the UN rights chief mentioned.

He mentioned it’s important to the safety of the human rights and dignity of refugees and migrants looking for safety that every one removals from the UK are carried out after assessing their particular particular person circumstances in strict compliance with worldwide human rights and refugee regulation.

A truthful, environment friendly and well-governed migration and asylum system is vital to making sure entry to safety for these in want and enabling the return residence of these with no lawful foundation to stay, the UN officers mentioned.

Acknowledging the challenges introduced by the irregular motion of refugees and migrants, usually in harmful circumstances, the UN leaders nonetheless expressed grave concern that the laws would facilitate transfers below the UK-Rwanda asylum partnership, with solely restricted consideration of their particular person circumstances or any safety dangers.

They referred to as on the UK as a substitute topursue sensible cooperation with nations alongside the routes that refugees and migrants take, to strengthen safety and provide actual options. This contains increasing protected and common pathways to safety, they mentioned.

Progressively restrictive legal guidelines

The UN officers identified that the brand new laws is the third in a sequence of progressively restrictive legal guidelines which have eroded entry to refugee safety within the UK since 2022, together with via a ban on entry to asylum or different types of permission to remain within the UK for these arriving irregularly by way of a 3rd nation.

If applied, the brand new invoice would “pave the way in which for asylum seekers, together with households with youngsters, to be summarily despatched to Rwanda to current their asylum claims, with no prospect of return to the UK”, they mentioned.

The brand new invoice may even drastically restrict the flexibility for asylum seekers to problem or enchantment elimination selections, with determination makers and judges required to conclusively deal with Rwanda as a “protected” nation when it comes to defending asylum seekers, no matter any proof on the contrary, now or sooner or later, the UN officers mentioned.

This case is much more regarding given the laws expressly authorises the UK Authorities to ignore any protecting interim cures from the European Court docket of Human Rights, the UN chiefs warned.