Declare:

Donald Trump criticized pay raises for United Auto Employees (UAW) union members throughout a Fox Information interview in 2008, saying, “They get their little 5 p.c. They get one other two p.c. They get one other three p.c, 4 p.c … and abruptly they’re making more cash than the folks that personal the corporate.”

Score:

Rating: Correct Attribution

Score: Appropriate Attribution

Context:

Within the authentic interview, Trump argued that auto producers wanted to “make a a lot better deal” with the union on pay raises. He additionally stated that he believed the union’s employees had been “unbelievable” and referred to as Ron Gettelfinger, who was the president of UAW on the time, “one of many best representatives for a gaggle of individuals” that he had “ever seen.” An extended video and partial transcription of the interview are introduced within the story under.

 

In late January 2024, the @BidenHQ account on X — an official rapid-response arm of U.S. President Joe Biden‘s reelection marketing campaign — posted a quick video clip from an previous Fox Information interview with the caption, “Trump on union employees: ‘They get their little 5 p.c, they get one other 2 p.c… Swiftly they’re making more cash than the folks that personal the corporate.'”

This was a real video clip from an interview that initially aired on Fox Information on Dec. 17, 2008.

Through the interview, Fox host Neil Cavuto requested Trump about his ideas relating to a possible government-assistance package deal for the car business, which was struggling financially on the time in gentle of the 2008 financial crisis. Trump additionally spoke on the truth that the United Auto Employees (UAW) union had simply days earlier agreed to a collection of concessions to assist hold the business afloat. A $17.4 billion bailout of GM and Chrysler was announced by then-U.S. President George W. Bush on Dec. 19, two days after the interview aired.

The clip was reposted by the Biden marketing campaign account on Jan. 31, 2024, simply days following the announcement from UAW President Shawn Fain who stated that the union can be endorsing the sitting president’s reelection. The union beforehand endorsed Biden in 2020 and former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in 2016.

Historical past of Reposts of the Interview

Two video clips from the interview had been beforehand reposted on X in September 2023, together with one which genuinely confirmed Trump saying, “I believe that the unions are actually, actually hurting very badly what is going on on with the auto [industry].” The clips had been additionally printed on DailyKos.com and on the Daily Kos YouTube channel:

Transcript and Longer Video, for Context

The Media Issues for America web site hosted a lengthier clip from the Trump interview that lasted practically 4 minutes. A transcript and video of the total interview didn’t seem like publicly out there on-line.

Snopes transcribed the longer video under. Highlights have been bolded:

CAVUTO: Would you bail out the auto business?

TRUMP: The auto business is such a fantastic query. And it is such an fascinating… this might be studied for years. Do you do it? Do you not do it? And I watched [Ron] Gettelfinger, the union head, on tv. He is likely one of the best representatives for a gaggle of folks that I’ve ever seen. You sit there and it seems like your grandfather is simply speaking to you, a fireplace chat, just like the individuals are ravenous within the union. After which I’m going to individuals and associates of mine which are within the auto enterprise, and he talks about two and three-year severance. He talks about, “You are taken care of for the remainder of your life, it doesn’t matter what occurs.” A catastrophe, a legacy that is a complete catastrophe. However you watch this man, I actually admit, they’ve one of many nice representatives I’ve ever seen. Since you watch him and also you virtually wish to write a verify to the union saying…

CAVUTO: So you do not suppose he is conceded sufficient?

TRUMP: I believe that the unions are actually, actually hurting very badly what is going on on with the autos, and, you recognize, I additionally actually suppose they make a very good product. I hear a lot. The issue is that the management does not discuss how good the product is. I purchase American. We purchase loads of vans and loads of issues American. They’re actually good merchandise and no person talks concerning the high quality. I hold listening to about how Japan makes this nice product. How different nations are making… We make a fantastic product. And by the best way, the union employees are unbelievable, however most likely they should take a minimize. However for those who hearken to [Ron] Gettelfinger, it is virtually just like the world has collapsed.

CAVUTO: However would you bail them out?

TRUMP: (lengthy sigh) There are such a lot of ways in which it may be saved. In the event that they do a Chapter 11.

CAVUTO: Nicely, chapter is an possibility.

TRUMP: In the event that they do a Chapter 11, and over time I’ve put corporations right into a Chapter 11. You negotiate from Chapter 11. It is a great energy.

CAVUTO: Did it be just right for you? You got here again from… they are saying it could possibly’t work for them as a result of individuals would not purchase from a bankrupt auto firm. They would not purchase vehicles.

TRUMP: Look, most of the individuals that you simply report about have taken corporations and put them into Chapter 11. Now, I would not wish to do it on a private foundation and I’ve by no means accomplished it on a private foundation. However, for those who have a look at WCI, it is Carl Icahn. In case you have a look at one thing else, it is anyone else. I imply, many, many individuals, you recognize, it does not get the publicity of the auto enterprise except after all I occur to do it through which case it will get loads of publicity…

CAVUTO: However Don, the auto guys say they’d be totally different as a result of chapter for them is just not an possibility, that it might be a scarlet letter and a stigma.

TRUMP: That is proper. They are saying individuals will not purchase vehicles.

CAVUTO: Do you purchase that?

TRUMP: Nicely, I completely do not as a result of I might relatively purchase a automobile than fly on an airline. When United Airways is bankrupt [or] when Delta Air Traces goes bankrupt, and I am imagined to be flying them, I might relatively have a automobile than fly on an airline, if that is the case. However, they did not lose any enterprise. Now, so long as they know the corporate goes to be round, it is not going to harm them one bit. In reality, individuals would really like it. However it’s a must to make a greater take care of the unions regardless of Gettelfinger’s good salesmanship. It is good. Regardless of that, it’s a must to make a a lot better take care of the unions. And it’s a must to make a greater take care of everyone. I imply, every thing. It is years and years of (inaudible).

And you recognize, I see it at my very own firm. Whereas my firm’s quite a bit newer, over time, we have now Christmas bonus time, proper? And we have accomplished effectively. Now, I pay anyone a bonus 20 years in the past. Then you definately give them a little bit extra, a little bit extra, a little bit extra. Now it is 20 years later. Swiftly, I am saying, “I am paying them an excessive amount of. I am paying them an excessive amount of.” I imply, I am paying some guys far more than I ought to be paying. You already know why? Time. Similar factor with the unions. They get a little bit improve. They get one other, one other… 40 or 50 years will go by…

CAVUTO: What do your guys get? Do you give them a condominium or what do you give them?

TRUMP: No, I simply give them bonuses. However you recognize, I at all times like to provide them a little bit extra…

CAVUTO: I do know it is not a hickory cheese log. I do know that.

TRUMP: No, I am not even speaking about top-level individuals. I am speaking about. You go a little bit bit, little bit, little bit, little bit… abruptly 20 years is up and now you are saying, “Man, that is some huge cash.” I am sitting behind my desk signing these checks.

CAVUTO: Nicely see, then they count on it, proper?

TRUMP: They count on it.

CAVUTO: December rolls round and, I believe, “Don’s gonna be good to me.”

TRUMP: You already know, it is the identical factor with the unions.

CAVUTO: That is proper.

TRUMP: They get their little 5 p.c. They get one other two p.c. They get one other three p.c, 4 p.c … and abruptly they’re making more cash than the folks that personal the corporate.

Further Notes

On Jan. 25, 2024, Cavuto interviewed Fain on Fox Information. Through the interview, Fain appeared to reference the remarks Trump made in 2008, telling Cavuto, “In 2008 [and] 2009, the financial recession, Donald Trump blamed the employees for what was flawed with these [auto] corporations.”

Additionally, on Dec. 10, 2008, only one week previous to Trump’s interview with Cavuto, he appeared on Fox Information for a special interview with host Greta Van Susteren, through which he additionally appeared to put some blame on unions for the disaster that the auto business was coping with on the time.

Sources:

Cassidy, John. “An Inconvenient Fact: It Was George W. Bush Who Bailed Out the Automakers.” The New Yorker, 16 Mar. 2012, https://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/an-inconvenient-truth-it-was-george-w-bush-who-bailed-out-the-automakers.

“Donald Trump Assaults the UAW for Hanging in 2008.” YouTube, Each day Kos, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=acxjk1E3Lro.

Einenkel, Walter. “Watch Trump Complain about Paying Employees Nicely in 2008.” Each day Kos, 26 Sept. 2023, https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2023/9/26/2195481/-Watch-Trump-complain-about-paying-workers-well-in-2008.

“How Donald Trump Would Save the Auto Business and Extra.” Fox Information, 10 Dec. 2008, https://www.foxnews.com/story/how-donald-trump-would-save-the-auto-industry-and-more.

Howard, Phoebe Wall. “UAW President Shawn Fain Goes on Fox, Lists 5 Key Causes Why Trump Misplaced Union Endorsement.” Detroit Free Press, 27 Jan. 2024, https://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/2024/01/27/uaw-president-shawn-fain-fox-news-neil-cavuto-david-pakman/72379756007/.

Krisher, Tom, et al. “Employees Strike at All 3 Detroit Automakers, a New Tactic to Squeeze Firms for Higher Pay.” The Related Press, 15 Sept. 2023, https://apnews.com/article/auto-uaw-workers-strike-gm-ford-stellantis-7ce3ca9d94b911250d07556b7af376c7.

Megerian, Chris, et al. “Biden’s subsequent Local weather Hurdle: Engaging Individuals to Purchase Inexperienced.” The Related Press, 23 Jan. 2023, https://apnews.com/article/biden-politics-united-states-government-business-climate-and-environment-f145b24414ff245f491fd68257b3db60.

Merica, Dan. “United Auto Employees Endorses Clinton over Trump | CNN Politics.” CNN, 26 Could 2016, https://www.cnn.com/2016/05/25/politics/hillary-clinton-uaw-endorsement/index.html.

Shepardson, David. “United Auto Employees Union Endorses Biden for President.” Reuters, 21 Apr. 2020, https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKCN2232NS/.

The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. “Monetary Disaster of 2007–08.” Brittanica, https://www.britannica.com/money/financial-crisis-of-2007-2008.

“UAW Endorses Biden for 2024 | Fox Information Video.” Fox Information, 25 Jan. 2024, https://www.foxnews.com/video/6345567954112.

“Video: Your World With Neil Cavuto from Fox Information.” Media Issues for America, 17 Dec. 2008, https://www.mediamatters.org/media/4011792.

Vlasic, Invoice. “U.A.W. Makes Concessions to Assist Automakers.” The New York Instances, 3 Dec. 2008, https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/04/business/04auto.html.


At present Information Prime Newsmaac

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here